Sign up | Login with →

Comments by Gail Tverberg Subscribe

On Eight Energy Myths Explained

This paper was written during the period when electricity from nuclear energy was expected to be "too cheap to meter." In a later paper, he talks about using the energy from nuclear to "reverse combustion" and make liquid fuels.

By 1976, Hubbert had changed his view of what might work. He showed solar energy taking over from fossil fuels, instead of nuclear. Solar doesn't scale nearly as well. I think the issue was disillusionment with nuclear, rather than conviction that solar would really work.


May 2, 2014    View Comment    

On Eight Energy Myths Explained

Don't count on coal-to-liquid operations. For one thing they require a lot of water. If a country has a lot of coal, as China does, it doesn't necessarily have water to go with it. The US West has a lot of coal, too, but not the water needed to produce a liquid fuel from oil. 

THe other issue is that the liquid produced from coal is expensive. It also is very high in CO2 emissions, because of the extra coal burned in the process, besides the coal that goes to make the oil. With the high cost, it has detrimental effects on the economy--people can afford fewer other goods, so there will be lay offs. 

May 1, 2014    View Comment    

On Eight Energy Myths Explained

The problem that ties all of the shortages together is cost. We can fix one problem, or another, or another, but in the end, the solution costs more. Our wages don't rise though, espeically those of young people.

So, in the end, the problem we end up with is financial. Young people can't afford to pay back their student loans, or to buy new homes and cars. The government can't collect enough taxes to pay all of the benefits it has paid out. At some point, something has to give. 

Many economies have collapsed in the past. Quite often what happens in that the government collapses--think of the Former Soviet Union. People are not looking in the right direction to find the problems that are building up.

April 29, 2014    View Comment    

On Oil Limits and Climate Change: How They Fit Together

I am not sure what you are quoting. It is certainly not something I wrote.

April 15, 2014    View Comment    

On Oil Limits and Climate Change: How They Fit Together

We badly need globalization, to keep our current "model" going. But it seems to be going by the side now. Fighting over resources, when they are in short supply, has been going on as long as there have been humans, I expect. We had a temporary lull when fossil fuels were more abundant.

April 14, 2014    View Comment    

On The Absurdity of US Natural Gas Exports

You have to make the hydgoen somehow, using energy . Storing it then gets to be a problem. It iven tends to leak out of tanks, once stored. I am not convinced it is a very practical solution.

April 4, 2014    View Comment    

On The Absurdity of US Natural Gas Exports


I think you are right. Most of the export capacity will never be built. It is easier to get approvals on the general concept from the EIA than the actual funding for these projects, with a number of other projects likely producing lower cost gas. Obviously ships are needed as well, or the natural gas won't go far.


April 4, 2014    View Comment    

On Oil Limits and the Economy: One Story, Not Two

Thanks for the suggestion with respect to "Surviving Progress." I am not a movie watcher, so missed it.

I think that where the film and I differ relates to how much we can do about the situation. The film (as I understand it from the reviews) argues that we can save ourseleves by scaling back.

If our current situation really is the result of a physics related problem, then our ability to voluntarily scale back is very limited. Physics determines that economies with the greatest energy use are the most successful. Also, even if we scale back, there is the issue of finite resources still depleting, even if more slowly. 

March 23, 2014    View Comment    

On Reaching Debt Limits: With or Without China's Problems, We Have a Problem

Demand is affordability, in my book. Demand goes way down, if you get laid off your job. We need cheap oil (and cheap other fuels) to have today's jobs. It is lack of jobs that leads to lack of demand.

March 13, 2014    View Comment    

On Reasons for our Energy Predicament: An Overview

It may seem peculiar. I suggest reading my article fromthe journal Energy. A version is available free on my website Oil Supply Limits and the Continuing Financial Crisis. It is more general than simply about the recession.

James Hamilotn has an article that is very specific to the recession. It is called Causes and Consequences of the Oil Shock of 2007-2008.


March 7, 2014    View Comment    

On Reasons for our Energy Predicament: An Overview

What I look at is our financial problems that we have today, that are largely papered over by Quantitative Easing. These financial problems were largely caused by high oil prices. In fact, the Great Recession of 2008-2009 was caused by high oil prices. 

We can't keep QE going much longer. We don't have time (or money) to change to other fuels. Wind and solar have so much costs involved, that they tend to put us on the down escalator, rather than the up escalator. We don't have solutions in other fuels.


March 6, 2014    View Comment    

On Reasons for our Energy Predicament: An Overview

The issue with financial and political limits is they hit different countries at different times.

Oil exporters with declines are hit especially hard. Look at Egypt, Syria, Yemen, Venezuela. They are already experiencing the kind of effects that a person would expect of countries with limits.

The Former Soviet Union is an example of an exporter that broke up, when oil prices dropped too low. Once prices rose again, and the world economy was healthier, they were able to raise production again.

Countries that are big users (and importers) of oil are especially hit as well. Greece is an example. So is Spain.

Quantitative Easing has been able to hide a lot of problems. The question is how long it can continue.



March 6, 2014    View Comment