Tesla Motors will have its IPO today. The Nissan LEAF electric vehicle sold out shortly after it was announced, many of the orders coming from first-time Nissan customers. The Chevy Volt may even hit the showroom later this year.
It certainly seems as if the age of the electric car is upon us. But hold on a minute. Let not all the hype keep us from seeing the speedbumps -- and maybe a few roadblocks in the way of a complete transition on our roadways.
Don't get me wrong, I believe the battery electric vehicle (or BEV for short) is the vehicle of the future. But this new generation of electric vehicles will have lots of challenges, including battery technology, range, and charging.
Let's take range. Today, we are used to driving 300 miles or so before having to pull into a gas station and, after inserting our credit card, choosing the grade, and popping the nozzle in the tank, we can be refueled and ready to go before we've had a chance to clean the windshield.
Contrast that with the currently planned charging experience for electric vehicles. Drive 100 miles and you need to charge it -- the LEAF will take 8 hours for a full charge at 200 volts -- and there is currently very little infrastructure to support electric vehicle charging.
You can get around this by increasing the number or density of batteries in a vehicle, which will add weight and cost, but as battery technology improves the weight and cost, life and range will increase.
Charging, however, still remains an issue. I'm concerned about the vision of the future that imagines hundreds of thousands of charging stations around the country, in cities, parking garages, and on-the-street parking (perhaps replacing the meters that have gone the way of the parking kiosk). That seems like an awful lot of infrastructure needing to be built.
And what about that volatile mix of bad weather and high voltage. Imagine the housewife, parking in the Whole Foods lot, plugging in while she goes in for groceries. She comes out, and some idiot parking next to her has dislodged the plug. Not only does she not have the charge she needs to go pick up Junior from day care, but now she's dealing with a live wire on a wet macadam. Doesn't sound like the way to go to me.
I've even seen plans for "battery replacement stations" where you drive in and your old battery is swapped out for a new one -- the batteries are on a huge circular conveyor. The Pep Boys, Manny, Moe, and Jack, are probably salivating at that prospect. That doesn't seem feasible to me.
Which is why I was encouraged by this video from the UK-based HaloIPT of an alternative future featuring wireless, dynamic charging based upon inductive power transfer technology.
Momentum Dynamics, a Malvern, PA-based company I've written about before on this blog, also has a technology that may help advance the vision depicted above.
As Andy Daga, CEO of Momentum Dynamics said to me recently, the battery electric vehicle industry "Needs three things: 1) improved battery technology (this is coming), improved vehicle integration of new technologies (also in the works), and finally, improvements in the technology and distribution of charging technology."
Of course, that is what Andy and his company are focused on, and which he feels "is absolutely critical to the industry."
I hope for the sake of the electric vehicle market that the Tesla IPO ($TSLA) goes well. I have concerns that, like $AONE, it will go from 0 to 60 and come to a screeching halt, like, well, a Tesla Roadster as it approaches a speed trap. (That won't be good for future cleantech IPOs -- some companies have already pulled their plans this year).
But I have larger concerns that we are ignoring the looming issues facing the electric vehicle industry that may well prevent it from going the distance.
With Tesla IPO, Has the Age of Electric Vehicles Arrived?
- 845 reads
- Feed: the green skeptic™
- Original article
calls The Energy Collective...
“...a valuable aggregator of views on one of the prime challenges of our time - how to provide the energy required to foster a smooth path beyond 'peak us' while cutting the risks of economic turmoil, resource conflicts or disruptive climate change. ” Read the post
![]()
Marc Gunther is a writer, speaker and consultant, who focuses on business and the environment as well as the author of "Faith and Fortune".
Read more »
Christine Hertzog is a consultant, author, and a professional explainer focused on Smart Grid.
Read more »
Jesse Jenkins is the director of energy and climate policy at the Breakthrough Institute.
Read more »
Geoffrey Styles is Managing Director of GSW Strategy Group, LLC and an award-winning blogger.
Read more »
Dan Yurman is a nuclear energy blogger and writes regularly for Fuel Cycle Week.
Read more »
Siemens Answers For Industry Conference
When: Tue, 2010-08-24 08:00
Smart Grid & Smart Cities Conference in Amsterdam November 9th & 10th 2010
When: Thu, 2010-09-02 09:00
Siemens Answers. The Smart Grid Tour - Montreal
When: Sun, 2010-09-12 08:00
World Energy Congress - 2010
When: Sun, 2010-09-12 08:00
Siemens Answers. The Smart Grid Tour - New York City
When: Tue, 2010-09-28 08:00
GridWeek 2010
When: Mon, 2010-10-18 08:00
Members, click here to find out what you need to know about our new site!














Nathan Wilson said:
When faced with a choice of going to the gas station every 300 miles, or pulling my electric car into my garage every night or every 100 miles (assuming I have a wireless charging pad), the electric option is the clear winner. Why would anyone pay luxury car money for a car that needs gas? Ok, so maybe they'd still sell a few gas powered trucks for pulling boats and such.
- reply
- 0 points
Thu, 2010-07-01 00:55 — Nathan Wilson (not verified)JesseJenkins said:
Great post! Any idea from talking to the Momentum Dynamics folks how much each one of their wireless charging pads costs? They present a very compelling vision of these devices being ubiquitous across the city and even highway networks, but that clearly is only possible if these things are pretty darned cheap. At $2,200 a pop, the Nissan Leaf home charging station is clearly far to expensive to be found at every parking spot in the city. Thanks,
Jesse
- reply
- 0 points
Wed, 2010-06-30 12:35 — Jesse JenkinsPost new comment