Distributed Generation, Electricity Storage, and the Utility of the Future
Last week I attended InterSolar North America 2013 in San Francisco, the largest solar energy trade show in the United States. I left with two major impressions: First, based on the traffic at the NAATBatt booth, the solar industry is finally waking up to the potential importance of electricity storage. Three years ago, when NAATBatt last attended the show, storage was no more than a curiosity. The attitude today is quite different. If not quite yet rushing out to buy storage systems, solar developers are starting to think seriously about storage. It is starting to make sense.
My second impression was perhaps even more significant: Distributed solar generation of electricity is poised for explosive growth. Improved technology, lower cost solar panels, greater transparency in electricity pricing, increased concern about grid reliability and rising electricity prices are all pushing solar energy towards economic parity with traditional sources of electricity—and perhaps even past it in some jurisdictions. The real action appears to be in the types of distributed commercial and residential systems that are increasingly dotting rooftops around the country rather than large, utility scale projects. Distributed solar installations in California are growing dramatically. The economics that are driving demand in California are likely to start spreading to other jurisdictional markets soon.
The significance of my second impression, however, is not really about the impending growth of distributed solar energy. Rather it is about the implications of that growth on the business of traditional electric utilities. Widespread deployment of distributed generation resources will be fundamentally disruptive to the way the electricity grid has been organized in the United States since its inception. The business model of the electric utility is based on the assumption that a utility will sell the generation, transmission and/or distribution of electricity. What role will utilities play on a grid where electricity, or at least a significant amount of it, is generated by the ultimate consumer and no transmission or distribution is required?
The answer probably lies in the fact that the grid as we know will not go away entirely, even if distributed generation becomes the principal source of electricity for consumers. The grid will remain a vital source of backup power, a source of primary power for some, and, significantly, a resource for owners of distributed generation to monetize the value of electricity they cannot use themselves, by wheeling it to other users on the grid. The role of the utility of the future may be less involved with selling electricity than with managing and balancing the needs of various stakeholders on the grid. That includes the needs of distributed generators, whose actions the utilities will not be able fully to control.
And that brings us to electricity storage. Storage is a near to ideal tool for managing a grid comprised of independent distributed generators. On the grid of the future, electricity storage will provide a mechanism by which electric utilities can buffer generation they do not control and dispatch it, at the time of the utility’s choosing, to provide the highest possible value of services to the grid. Storage will not just be useful to the utilities of the future. Storage will be central to their core mission.
It is far from clear, however, that most utilities yet see this future. Virtually all of the inquiries we received at the NAATBatt booth at InterSolar concerned storage systems that would be located “inside the meter”—owned by consumers rather than by utilities. This despite the fact that, objectively speaking, storage would theoretically be far more valuable on the utility side of the meter, where it could more easily be aggregated and dispatched to other consumers or used for other functions on the grid. It almost appears that utilities are ceding the incipient market for storage to distributed generators. If so, this would be a bad mistake for the utility industry.
If the market for storage grows up “inside the meter”, rather than on the utility side of the meter, there is good reason to believe that utilities will have a hard time getting that market back. In the absence of any attempt by utilities to capture the storage market, third party aggregators and other business entities are likely to step in and fill the need. Once they have done so, it will likely be quite difficult for a regulated utility to try to step in and try to compete against them. By ignoring storage technology in the short run and letting the market for storage grow up inside the meter rather than out on the utility side, the utility industry may be shutting itself out of a service offering which, in the long run, may prove to be central to utilities’ new role as power managers rather than as power sellers.
A wise utility should be thinking today about the forces that will disrupt the electricity power markets over the next few decades. Distributed solar generation will be one of those disruptive forces with storage being a key driver of its value. Utilities that focus only on the short term challenges of storage, and not on its implication for their future businesses, are doing themselves and their shareholders a serious disservice.
The winners and losers among electric utility companies in the new, distributed generation-dominated world are being decided by the decisions that utilities are making (or not making) today. Those that are not investing in the technologies that will allow them to manage power on the grid—such as electricity storage—and, worse, are allowing those technologies to be developed and deployed by non-utility competitors are simply consigning themselves to eventual irrelevance. That may work well for managers with limited time horizons. But it will wreak havoc on investors and eventually on rate payers.
The future world of distributed power generation is coming. Judging by what I saw at InterSolar, it may be coming sooner than many believe. Smart utilities should move aggressively to own electricity storage technology on the grid—a technology that will be a key component of distributed generation and central to the power manager role of the utility of the future.
Photo Credit: Solar Energy Generation/shutterstock
Jim Greenberger is the Executive Director of NAATBatt, a trade association of companies in the advanced battery industry working to grow the market for advanced batteries in the United States, primarily in automotive and grid-connected energy storage applications.
Other Posts by James Greenberger
The Energy Collective
- Rod Adams
- Scott Edward Anderson
- Charles Barton
- Barry Brook
- Dick DeBlasio
- Simon Donner
- Big Gav
- Michael Giberson
- James Greenberger
- Lou Grinzo
- Tyler Hamilton
- Christine Hertzog
- David Hone
- Gary Hunt
- Jesse Jenkins
- Sonita Lontoh
- Jesse Parent
- Jim Pierobon
- Vicky Portwain
- Tom Raftery
- Joseph Romm
- Robert Stavins
- Robert Stowe
- Geoffrey Styles
- Alex Trembath
- Gernot Wagner
- Dan Yurman