Carbon Dioxide Can Be A Resource Rather Than A Waste Product
I recently wrote an article titled “Carbon Conversion is Key to Solving Climate Change Problems” where I discussed the need to develop markets for carbon dioxide based products. Rather than rely on underground carbon sequestration that treats CO2 as waste, carbon conversion treats CO2 as a resource. The reason is simple: profits. By creating financial incentives a robust market can be developed to utilize carbon dioxide as an industrial feedstock and hopefully absorb decisive quantities of CO2 away from the atmosphere where it is driving climate change.
I received a fair amount of skepticism in the comments on my article. Carbon utilization is not a widely discussed concept in America, but it is a growing field with research programs in the USA and Europe, and new businesses bringing these products and services to market.
This simple chart demonstrates that carbon dioxide emissions are expected to grow in coming decades despite the growth in renewable energy alternatives. The developing world, particularly China and India, are adding coal faster than all other power sources. Nuclear power could displace a lot of coal use for power but faces years of political and technical headwinds and the industry will be challenged to maintain market share in the near term as older plants face decommissioning. Switching coal for natural gas is helpful in lowering CO2 but is not decisive on its own with regards to climate change. Electrification of transportation systems may reduce petroleum use but pushes energy demand back to the power grid and therefore increases demand for coal. In short, CO2 emissions are going up.
Efforts are needed to address carbon dioxide directly. Captured CO2 can be a useful industrial feedstock and has a wide variety of potential applications that can safely sequester it from the atmosphere while also displacing fossil fuels as a raw material. Carbon utilization offers policy makers options to offset the costs of the reducing CO2 emissions, by converting the environmental liability into a productive asset.
But don’t take my word for it, what follows is a sampling of some of the developments in this exciting new field. Everything in italics is taken from third parties that are actively pursuing carbon utilization.
Dr. Gernot Klotz, Executive Director Research and Innovation at Cefic (European Chemical Industry Council) stressed the need for a change in mentality towards CO2, saying: "Europe can no longer afford to look at CO2 as pollution or waste to be disposed of; but rather as a renewable resource for the future.”
CO2 as a feedstock for chemistry can be used in many different ways, such as renewable energy storage and as an ingredient to make polymers and new materials. The next step will be to make CO2 a key enabler for artificial photosynthesis via chemical processes.
Dr. Klotz sees CO2 as the only renewable resource Europe has in abundance and can play a vital role in ensuring Europe’s future as a competitive economy.
In early October Prof Gabriele Centi from the University of Messina gave a technical overview of the potential of CO2 as a feedstock during a Cefic sponsored session at the European Innovation Summit in Brussels. He said that “CO2 is neither a polluter nor a waste” and that it could be “a raw material that enabled change for society.”
He also sees CO2 as a valuable carbon source and a key element to realise energy and resource efficiency and introduce new renewable energy concepts. The carbon-based economy would provide a new scenario for sustainable chemicals production that integrated biomass and CO2 as feedstocks for a “new chemistry for the future”.
The (re)use of CO2 could be a massive opportunity for Europe he concluded. It could exploit a currently untapped resource and contribute to reducing GHG emissions and be a major driver of innovation and growth.
DNV, the respected Norwegian classification and risk management society, issued a position paper that provides technical detail and some market estimates for CO2 utilization.
There are essentially three pathways for utilizing CO2: conversion of CO2 into fuel, utilization of CO2 as a feedstock for chemicals, and non-conversion use of CO2. The various utilization technologies together have the potential to reduce CO2 emissions by at least 3.7 gigatons/year (Gt/y) (approximately 10 % of total current annual CO2 emissions), both directly and by reducing use of fossil fuels. However, much greater reductions are possible through wider adoption of these technologies.
It has been estimated that by 2035, the world will produce 15 Gt/y of CO2 from burning liquid fuels. In addition to generating biomass, CO2 can be converted via chemical and electrochemical processes to other energy storage chemicals, such as syngas, formic acid, methane, ethylene, methanol, and dimethyl ether (DME).
An alternative pathway is to convert CO2 into chemical feedstock. The entire portfolio of commodity chemicals are currently manufactured from a few primary building blocks or platform chemicals in the fossil-based chemical industry. CO2 can be used as a source material and, utilizing renewable energy sources and water, can be converted into a similar suite of building block chemicals.
Insertion of CO2 into epoxides to manufacture various polymeric materials is an exciting technology as it not only utilizes CO2, but also avoids using fossil feedstock and creating CO2 emissions. It has been estimated that the various chemical conversion pathways can consume approximately 0.3 to 0.7 Gt/y of CO2
Conversion of CO2 into inorganic minerals that may be used in building materials is being pursued by some companies. This involves a combination of electrochemical reactions to generate the alkaline reactant and necessary mineralization reactions. Initial estimates suggest that even if 10 % of the world’s building materials were to be replaced by such a source, consumption of 1.6Gt/y CO2 would result CO2 can also be used in various processes without first converting it into other chemical forms. The injection of supercritical CO2 into depleted oil wells to enhance the further recovery of oil is well established. Indeed, this is presently the only commercially viable technology for carbon capture and storage (CCS). It has been estimated that CO2 injection can increase oil recovery from a depleting well by about 10 to 20 % of the original oil in place. Similarly, CO2 can be used to recover methane from unmined coal seams. It has been estimated that in the U.S. alone, 89 billion barrels of oil could technically be recovered using CO2, leading to a storage of 16 Gt of CO2 in the depleted oil reservoirs . The use of supercritical CO2 as a solvent in processing many chemicals (e.g., flavor extraction) is also well established. New uses of supercritical CO2 in chemical processing are emerging, and have the added benefit of reducing water usage. Supercritical CO2 is also being explored as a heat transfer fluid for some geothermal applications. These non-conversion methods of utilization constitute a significant fraction of the total CO2 emissions.
I wrote about two new technology firms using CO2 as a feedstock previously.
Novomer uses CO2 as a feedstock for polymers and plastics.
Joule is using genetically modified bacteria, sunlight and CO2 to produce ethanol and diesel.
Skyonic Corporation has developed a mineralization process for scrubbing industrial flue gasses. Skyonic’s first for-profit carbon mineralization plant is under construction and scheduled to be completed this year.
Skyonic’s SkyMine® technology removes CO2 from industrial waste streams through co-generation of saleable carbonate and/or bicarbonate materials. In addition to capturing and mineralizing CO2, the SkyMine® process cleans SOx and NO2 from the flue gas, and removes heavy metals such as mercury. Existing power plants and industrial plants can be retrofitted with SkyMine®. Successful implementation of the SkyMine® technology establishes pathways for mitigating CO2 in areas where geologic storage, the predominant competing CO2 sequestration technology, is not an optimal solution.
A SkyMine® plant can be retrofitted to stationary emitters to economically remove CO2 from the exhaust stream and transform it into solids instead of a gas. Solid carbonates and bicarbonates can be profitably sold to market and are ideal for long-term, safe storage such as minefill or landfill. Solid storage of CO2 means that there is no need for pipeline transport, injection, or concern about CO2 re-release, as with other CO2 capture and sequestration technologies.
Another key advantage of the SkyMine® process is its scalability, as it allows an industrial or power plant owner to configure the degree of CO2 removal anywhere from 10% to 99%. This is important because industrial plants and power plants around the world have unique designs requiring different CO2 removal configurations.
The SkyMine® technology can be operated at a profit, due to the sale of byproducts. The solid carbonates and bicarbonates are saleable for use in bio-algae applications. SkyMine® also produces green chemicals, such as hydrochloric acid, bleach, chlorine, and hydrogen, which are also profitable and can replace less environmentally-friendly products in market.
The fact that the SkyMine® process removes virtually all SOX, NO2, and mercury and other heavy metals that would otherwise be emitted by the plant means it can replace existing scrubber technologies and eliminate hundreds of millions of dollars in capital expense and tens of millions of dollars in ongoing expenses.
CO2 Solutions uses enzymes to boost the productivity of solvent scrubbers used to capture CO2.
CO2 Solutions' technology addresses the high-cost barrier to Carbon Capture & Sequestration (CCS) created by conventional solvent-based CO2 capture processes. The technology, inspired by nature, utilizes the extremely powerful enzyme catalyst which efficiently manages carbon dioxide in humans and other living organisms, carbonic anhydrase.
For example, it efficiently manages the respiratory process in humans. Carbonic anhydrase is the most powerful catalyst known for the hydration of CO2, that is, converting carbon dioxyde to bicarbonate and protons.
The technology platform uses CA to dramatically accelerate the capture of CO2 with energy-efficient solvents. With these solvents, the use of the enzyme technology provides an economically attractive carbon capture solution with efficient capture and lower energy consumption.
In essence, the technology is an ‘industrial lung’ which takes advantage of CA’s capacity for the highly efficient capture and release of carbon dioxide in natural systems, adapted to industrial gas effluent streams. The approach follows in the footsteps of other enzymes successfully deployed to increase the efficiency of industrial processes, from biofuels to detergents to food production.
Nobel Laureate George Olah, a professor of chemistry at the University of Southern California, argued: Let’s chemically recycle CO2 – just like plants do. Methanol would provide renewable fuels, synthetic hydrocarbon products while stemming global warming.
Carbon Recycling International has followed Prof. Olah’s lead and has constructed successful pilot plants for producing methanol from CO2.
The pilot plant has been operating since 2007. It is an experimental facility for testing process flow sheets for carbon dioxide to liquid fuels. The lab can produce .05 million liters a year for fuel blending demonstration.
First Commercial Plant
The George Olah Renewable Methanol Plant has a production capacity of 5 million liters per year. Its purpose is to improve plant economics for building larger plants and to gain operating experience, which includes validation of distribution channels and logistics of Renewable Methanol in Iceland and the EU. Operation of the plant began in Q4 2011 at Svartsengi.
NewCO2Fuels Israel based New CO2 Fuels (NCF) has announced successful completion of Stage 1 Proof of Concept testing for high-temperature dissociation of carbon dioxide (CO2; as contained in industrial emissions) into carbon monoxide (CO) and oxygen. Two technologies demonstrated in Israel's Weizmann Institute of Science are being co-developed: (1) CO2 emissions to gaseous and liquid fuels, and (2) a solar thermal system that can produce the 1200 degrees Centigrade necessary to drive that dissociation and catalysis. In Stage 1 testing, the rate of dissociation has been increased by a factor of 200, while costs have been reduced by about a third from initial trials. The same system used for CO2 dissociation also is effective in dissociating water to hydrogen and oxygen; combining CO and H2 creates a synthetic fuel gas that can also be catalyzed to produce liquid fuel. In Stage 2 testing during the first quarter of 2014, the CO2 dissociation rate is expected to be quadrupled, and the thermochemical system will be integrated with NCF's solar thermal technology. NCF expects to start commercial scale reactor development later this year, once Stage 2 testing is completed.
The Centre for Innovation in Carbon Capture and Storage at Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, Scotland is an interdisciplinary, innovative, and international leading centre for research at the interface between science and engineering.
Here is a good paper from Penn State University.
The Journal of CO2 Utilization offers a single, multi-disciplinary, scholarly platform for the exchange of novel research in the field of CO2 re-use for scientists and engineers in chemicals, fuels and materials.
The emphasis will be on the dissemination of leading-edge research from basic science to the development of new processes, technologies and applications. This includes CO2 as a feedstock in the chemical, energy and materials sectors, and utilization in general to help minimize environmental impact.
Conferences are being held.
Brussels, Germany 30-31 October
The strong carbon pricing and equivalent regulatory mechanism will ultimately be necessary to drive widespread commercial deployment of carbon dioxide utilisation technologies.
Responding to these economics and market drivers, some of the world`s largest players in power and other industrial sectors are investing in projects to more profitably utilise CO2 for diverse industrial applications. The new environment has created an exciting tipping point in strategic partnering, investment, and construction that is driving rapid growth in commercialisation of CO2 utilisation technologies.
Mature CO2 reuse technologies as Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR) can play a lead role in CO2 utilisation, though the emerging technologies in petrochemical, biochemical, fuel, and power energy sector are already making inroads.
San Diego, CA, February 19-20
CARBON DIOXIDE DOES NOT HAVE TO BE A WASTE PRODUCT!
The perception of carbon dioxide as a waste product is being challenged by a new wave of industrial applications. CO₂ utilization is now set to play an important role in the development of alternative fuels, ways to tackle climate change and the synthesis of high value chemicals.
*Overcoming Barriers to Wider Adoption of CO₂Utilization Applications*
*CO₂ as an Asset: Potential Benefits & Challenges for Society*
*CO₂ Utilization Technologies to Scale CO₂ Emissions Without Subsidies*
*Capture and Reuse of CO₂ & NOx from Stationary Engine Flue Gas for Algae Production*
*Deployment of Enzymatic Technology for Low-Cost CO₂ Mitigation*
*Carbon-Negative Fuels from Algae Biomass, Wastewater & CO₂*
*Sustainable Production of Green Feed for Transportation Fuels from CO₂ & Hydrogen*
*Achieving Efficient Separation and Utilization of CO₂ in the Production of Fine Chemicals*
*Development of a High Efficiency Supercritical CO₂ Hot Gas Turbo-Expander & Low Cost Heat Exchangers*
2 - 3 December 2014, Haus der Technik, Essen, Germany
Carbon Dioxide – raw material of the future
CO2 pipelines have been operating in the United States for almost 40 years, and there are approximately 3,600 miles of CO2 pipelines in operation today.
Today, CO2 is mainly transported in pipelines for industrial purposes. The majority of CO2 pipelines are found in North America, where there is over 30 years of experience in transporting CO2, mainly from natural deposits and gas processing plants for enhanced oil recovery (EOR). The only existing offshore pipeline for transporting CO2 is the Snøhvit pipeline, which has been transporting CO2 (obtained from natural gas extraction) through a 153 km seabed pipeline from Hammerfest in north Norway back to the Snøhvit field under the Barents Sea, since May 2008.
Let’s conclude with the eminent Secretary of Energy, Dr. Ernest J. Moniz. Sec. Moniz conducted an interview with David Biello of Scientific American in Dec. 2013.
What about carbon dioxide capture and storage? Where does that technology stand today? Is it as ready as the new Environmental Protection Agency regulations imply?
First of all, it's ready in the sense that the technology is clearly there. Clean Air Act regulations have always been, I think the official terminology is, "technology forcing." But there's no question it's available. It's happening now.
There is a plant in North Dakota that has been sending huge amounts of CO2 into Canada for enhanced oil recovery [EOR] for years now. It has sequestered in EOR I think 20 megatons of CO2. The capture technologies for post-combustion have been employed, too, of course.
There's no doubt the technology exists. In fact, I was down at Kemper County in Mississippi a month ago and saw the almost complete Southern Company [CO2 capture and storage] plant down there. It's a monster. It's 550 megawatts. It's almost complete, not quite, but in 2014. The company has its long-term contracts in place for [the purchase of] electricity, for sulfuric acid, for ammonia and for carbon dioxide. It built a 60-mile pipeline to connect down to oil fields in southern Mississippi.
Both of the facilities that Dr. Moniz is discussing, the Dakota Synfuels plant and the Kemper County plant, sell their captured CO2 for EOR as a profitable business. EOR is at the moment the only large scale, commercially viable option for CO2 sequestration available today. I have written about Dakota Synfuels here.
Treating CO2 as an asset represents a sea-change in the approach to limiting carbon dioxide pollution. Rather than punish fuel consumers through a punitive carbon tax, carbon utilization offers the possibility that capturing and sequestering CO2 could be a profitable enterprise with a growing market that could set off a virtuous cycle of ever improving carbon management techniques.
Other Posts by Edward Dodge
The Energy Collective
- Rod Adams
- Scott Edward Anderson
- Charles Barton
- Barry Brook
- Steven Cohen
- Dick DeBlasio
- Simon Donner
- Big Gav
- Michael Giberson
- James Greenberger
- Lou Grinzo
- Tyler Hamilton
- Christine Hertzog
- David Hone
- Gary Hunt
- Jesse Jenkins
- Sonita Lontoh
- Rebecca Lutzy
- Jesse Parent
- Jim Pierobon
- Vicky Portwain
- Tom Raftery
- Joseph Romm
- Robert Stavins
- Robert Stowe
- Geoffrey Styles
- Alex Trembath
- Gernot Wagner
- Dan Yurman